Home espresso

The same money, two completely different machines

These two come up together on every forum thread in this category, and the comparison is usually argued on the wrong axis. They are not competing on quality, because both make genuinely good espresso. They are competing on what kind of owner you want to be. One is engineered to remove decisions from you. The other hands you all of them and expects you to enjoy it.

What to buy

  1. 1. Breville Bambino Plus

    $400 – $700

    The smallest serious espresso machine most people should buy, and the one that gets to temperature fastest.

    What it does well
    Three seconds to heat up, an automatic milk wand that steams a genuinely good flat white without any technique, and a footprint that fits a rented kitchen.
    What is wrong with it
    The 54mm portafilter is a smaller accessory ecosystem than the 58mm standard, and the plastic body feels its price next to a Gaggia. There is no pressure gauge, so when a shot runs badly you are guessing at why.
    Check price on Amazon for Breville Bambino Plus (opens in a new tab)

  2. 2. Gaggia Classic Evo Pro

    $400 – $700

    The machine people still own in ten years, because every part of it can be replaced.

    What it does well
    A commercial 58mm portafilter, a metal body, and a repair and modification community large enough that nothing on it is ever unfixable. It rewards practice in a way the automatic machines do not.
    What is wrong with it
    It takes real technique and a real grinder to get anything good out of it, and the stock steam wand is slower and less forgiving than the Bambino. Expect a frustrating fortnight before your first genuinely good shot.
    Check price on Amazon for Gaggia Classic Evo Pro (opens in a new tab)

The verdict

For most people the Bambino Plus is the right answer, because the machine that gets used is the one that is ready when you are. Choose the Gaggia if you already know you enjoy the process, or if the idea of a machine you can repair yourself for the next decade appeals more than three-second heat-up does.

Questions people ask

Which one makes better espresso?
Neither, meaningfully, once you know what you are doing. Given the same beans, the same grinder and a competent operator, the shots are close enough that the difference is smaller than the difference between two bags of coffee. Anyone claiming a clear winner here is comparing their own technique on two machines rather than the machines.
Which is faster to make a coffee on?
The Bambino, decisively. It is ready in about three seconds from cold, so it fits a weekday morning. The Gaggia needs several minutes to heat up properly and rewards leaving it on for longer than that. If your coffee happens in a hurry before work, this single difference matters more than everything else on this page.
Which one steams milk better?
The Bambino for a beginner, the Gaggia for someone with practice. The Bambino automates it to a genuinely good result with no skill at all. The Gaggia has a manual wand that is slower and less forgiving, but gives you full control over texture once you can use it, and it never does something you did not ask for.
Which will last longer?
The Gaggia, and not by a small margin. It is a metal-bodied machine with a commercial 58mm portafilter and a repair community large enough that essentially nothing on it is unfixable. The Bambino is well-built but is not designed to be opened. If you want one machine for a decade, that is the argument.
Which should I buy?
Buy the Bambino if espresso is something you want to drink, and the Gaggia if espresso is something you want to do. That sounds glib but it is the actual decision. Both make good coffee, and the difference is entirely in how much of your attention the machine asks for.

Keep reading